Example: Comparing two ways of calculating the average velocity

You have learned about two ways of computing the average velocity. The arithmetic average is an approximation and it can be a poor one. Consider the driving from East Lansing to Chicago (222 miles or 358 km). To get to Chicago, you drive at 55.0 mph (24.6 $\dfrac{m}{s}$) for 1 hour and 66.8 mph (29.9 $\dfrac{m}{s}$) for 2.5 hours. Compare the average velocity to the arithmetic average velocity.

Setup

You will compare the two ways of computing the average velocity using the information provided and any information that you can collect or assume.

Facts

Lacking

Approximations & Assumptions

Representations

Solution

For this situation, the average velocity can be computed,

$$v_{avg,x} = \dfrac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{3.58\times10^5m}{3600 s + 9000 s} = 28.4 \dfrac{m}{s}$$

You can compare that to the arithmetic average velocity,

$$v_{avg,x} \approx \dfrac{v_i + v_f}{2} = \dfrac{24.6 \dfrac{m}{s} + 29.9 \dfrac{m}{s}}{2} = 27.3 \dfrac{m}{s}$$

You can see that the arithmetic average is (in this case) less than the average velocity. It also under-predicts how far you would have driven,

$$\Delta x = v_{avg,x} \Delta t = 27.3 \dfrac{m}{s} (3600s+9000s) = 3.43\times10^5 m = 343 km$$

which is leaves you at the “outskirts” of Chicago (about 15 $km$ away).